Skip to main content

Posts

1.6.1. The Rationality:

D.1. Rationality: To be aware of the implications of the given means and ends, of the contradictions therein, of the sacrifices necessitated by their logic, and, most important of all, to strategize is Rationality. E.1. By Rationality it is implied that: i. All freely available information about means and ends is acquired. All costlier is subject to cost-benefit. ii. All contradictions between ends are discovered. iii. All implications for pursuing multiple ends using available social and technical conditions are discovered. iv. All relative valuations of means given the ends are discovered, calculated. v. All sacrifices, costs, necessitated by reason are also discovered. vi. A consistent long run path for achieving conflicting goals is discovered as a consequence of studying a logical implication of means and ends. vii. By discovered, it means to logically deduce from the given, or an implication. viii. By logically deduce, it implies deliberation, and conscious awareness. ix. None o...

1.5.6. The Usefulness of Economic Laws:

D.1. The Usefulness of Economic Laws: Scarcity as defined in D.4 of 1.1.1, despite being considered by some as an empirical accident, is a regular phenomenon and thus demands more frequent use of the rules of inference regarding behaviour under scarcity of substitutable means or The Laws of Economics. E.1. We face scarcity everyday in all matters of choices, in simple or complex dealings, in small scale family or large scale global issues, we always face one single problem that our resources do not permit simultaneous gratification of all ends pursued by us, and this makes scarcity a regularity. We have only 24 hours and no machine can make earth revolve around sun slower than it does, or we have only our own bodies to do our own work and hiring exhausts limited financial resources, or we have only limited information and we know that we do not know all and sometimes cannot know more, or we have resources in a month what our labours can produce for that month regardless of living in a...

1.5.5. The Limitations of Economic Laws:

D.1. The Limitations of Economic Laws:  The laws of economics can only be applied to the study of behaviour, given the set of means and ends. The laws of economics do not and cannot explain the given means and ends themselves. (From 1.2.1). E.1. From 1.2.1 we know it is out of scope to discuss why someone has altruistic ends, or selfish, why someone has a certain set of means. Not only so, it would be irrational to try to apply the conclusion of the premises to the premises. The premises being the given ends and the given means, and the conclusion being the Laws. The 'If X is Y, and Y is Z, then X is Z' is a logically valid argument, and now to try to explain X is Y or Y is Z using X is Z is nothing but a futile endeavour, something logicians are not interested in doing. Hence, it is the limitation of Laws of Economics that they, being deductions, cannot explain the changes in given data, although they always need, as inputs, the changes in data but neither they need to nor the...

1.5.4. Economics as the Logic of Choice:

D.1. Economics as the Logic of Choice:  The 1.5.3. along with 1.4.1 implies that economics is nothing more and nothing less than pure logic as applied to special circumstances of relative scarcity of substitutable means, or simplify: Economics is the Logic of Choice Making. E.1. It is no wonder that Jevons was a logician, and so many successful economists were mathematicians.

1.5.3. The Role of Economic Laws Given the Problems of Empirics:

D.1. The Role of Economic Laws Given the Problems of Empirics:  The Economic Laws are simple rules of inference regarding human behaviour under conditions of scarcity of substitutable means and multiple ends which are needed for making sound explanations while using the real life data which is subject to its problems (described in 1.4.4). E.1. Just like formal logic provides overly simplified rules of inference which, to a lay mind, give an impression that they are tautological, or too simple, Laws in Economics too are simple rules of inference of Choice Making (See 1.2.?). Just like those simple rules with no apparent value are necessary for developing sound arguments based on observed information, the Laws of Economics too are necessary for making sound predictions regarding a behaviour change given the observed data which is subject to problems of 1.4.4. In simple words, just like rules of inference from formal logic are used along with observed facts to deduce something reasona...

1.5.2. Two General Problems of Empirics:

D.1. The Non-Uniformity: The causes active in one sample do not necessarily repeat, or change, in each next sample set of observations. E.1. The empirical observations are not governed by the uniform causations as in theory. If at one time the price had risen because demand had risen, another time it may be due to a taxation, another time against same demand a short supply of raw materials may trigger rise in price, or another time a negative technological shock (say flood) may reduce the supply against same demand, or what and what not. Moreover, there are factors beyond observation, or factors which may be specific to a particular data set (a country, a time etc). All of these imply that data generated by real life events is a large uncontrolled experiment data and to ignore it would be erroneous. D.2. The Non-Generality: The mathematical functions cannot yield meaningful results when data they use is generated by heterogenous, sometimes irrelevant, circumstances. E.2. Neither are ...

1.5.1. Role of Empirical Methods.

D.1. Role of Empirical Methods: Empirical Studies can assist in either defining, measuring, refining, or extending the theory within bounds of 1.1.1, and 1.2.1. E.1. There are at least four ways in which empirical work can, in fact, be of great benefit to the theory. However, beyond these four ways, mentioned below, there is no reason that a science whose method is deductive and is decided by its definition (See 1.4.1), such a subject engages in inductive reasoning to generate its laws, refine itself, extend it or somehow mostly depend on inductive logic, or empirical observations. 1. To Operationalize:  The operational definitions of abstract ideas are of key importance, if theory is to be applied for good use. For instance, theory uses the term "money" but in practice there is a whole lot of many things that can be treated as money. Which is treated as money, and which is not, is the task an empirical study may very well perform. This is called operational definition in r...