Skip to main content

1.3.1. The Universality of Relativity.


D.1. The Universality of Relativity: From 1.1.1 it follows that all meaningful propositions in economics describe a relation between scarcity of substitutable means and ends via our behaviour.


E.1. Since economics is a study of consequences, for behaviour, of the conditions of relative scarcity of means as compared to ends, it follows that all meaningful propositions in economics, either directly or indirectly, are about these consequences arising due to relations between partially permissive substitutable means and fully immutable ends. Since now all propositions relate, in a logically valid manner, with the fundamental problem – scarce-substitutable means in relation with multiple ends – every meaningful proposition now is only a proposition which shows this relation of means and ends.


A Logical Derivation can be:

i. Economics is the study of implication, for behaviour, of the means which are not fully permissive of simultaneous gratification of all ends. (From 1.1.1, 1.2.1)

ii. Therefore, propositions in Economics are propositions that describe the relation of scarce-substitutable means with multiple ends via human behaviour.

iii. Therefore, if there is a proposition that does not describe the relation of scarce-substitutable means with ends via our behaviour, it is not a proposition belonging to Economics. (It is contrapositive of ii presented as a conditional)

iv. A proposition that describes the relation of two predicates is a relative propositions.

E.2. Consider these two instances:

I have a preference for apples over any other fruit. 

The demand of a commodity rises as a result of fall in its price in relation to price of its substitute.

In these the phrases “a preference for apples over any other fruit”, and “ its price in relation to price of to its substitute” are predicate phrases which show relation among predicates 'apples', and 'other fruits', and 'its price', and 'price of its substitute' respectively.

v. A proposition that does not describe a relation of two predicates describes something in absolutes, or is an absolute proposition. Such as, I like apples.

vi. Therefore, an absolute proposition cannot describe the relation of predicates of our behaviour i.e. scarce substitutable means and our ends.

vii. Therefore, all absolutes propositions fall out of bounds of Economic discourse, and are meaningless.

viii. Conversely,  all meaningful propositions in Economics are relative propositions.


Reference: Chapter 03 of Robbins, L. (2007). An essay on the nature and significance of economic science.

Popular posts from this blog

Brainstorming: What is Significance of Conceptual Hierarchies?

Brainstorming: What is Significance of Conceptual Hierarchies? Notes: It is useful for every apprentice to brainstorm and organize their ideas on important topics. This helps recall, and also discover logical gaps, or other weaknesses. I have attempted to do the same here. You may use it to develop your own diagram to organize and refine your own thoughts around the question in the title. See Project Concept Maps (Slide on Concept Maps) for understanding how these diagrams were made. You may download the picture to see it full size (Left Click on the picture, and select Save As.)
Read more

Brainstorming: What is Economics?

Brainstorming: What is Economics? Notes: It is useful for every apprentice to brainstorm and organize their ideas on important topics. This helps recall, and also discover logical gaps, or other weaknesses. I have attempted to do the same here. You may use it to develop your own diagram to organize and refine your own thoughts around the question in the title. See Project Concept Maps (Slide on Concept Maps) for understanding how these diagrams were made. You may download the picture to see it full size (Left Click on the picture, and select Save As.)
Read more

Brainstorming: What is Importance of Attention Direction?

Brainstorming: What is Importance of Attention Direction? Notes: It is useful for every apprentice to brainstorm and organize their ideas on important topics. This helps recall, and also discover logical gaps, or other weaknesses. I have attempted to do the same here. You may use it to develop your own diagram to organize and refine your own thoughts around the question in the title. See Project Concept Maps (Slide on Concept Maps) for understanding how these diagrams were made. You may download the picture to see it full size (Left Click on the picture, and select Save As.)
Read more